Shot of True Crime | Israel Keyes

Copy of Top Ten Tuesday.png

The Rundown

Honestly, I think that the true crime world is getting pretty saturated, so I don’t want to do the same thing that has been done super well by so many people.

Instead, I want to do a little summary and provide you with those resources. If you are intrigued, you have the best and brightest to listen to or read. I’m going to try to stay off of reddit because, while there are awesome ideas and facts found there, I don’t want to get into speculation or go down some of those rabbit holes.

I’m always interested in sharing ideas though so message me or comment about your thoughts or tell me which crimes you are interested in seeing. It doesn’t have to be murder!

HUGE CONTENT WARNING: This is about a serial killer, he committed atrocious crimes including rape, murder, dismemberment. I don’t go into those details, but the resources below are explicit. Some of them contain interview audio etc.

I had to start my true crime posts with the story that gave me the idea. I think I first heard about Israel Keyes on My Favorite Murder and it was terrifying. He went under the radar for so long and continues to do so. He was caught in Texas after the murder of Samantha Koenig, an 18 year old barista. He STOLE HER RIGHT OUT OF THE KIOSK. In front of people and on video.

Can you imagine someone kidnapping you in front of others and no one sees or says a thing? We feel safe around large groups and he stole that false sense of safety away.

After his arrest, prosecutors found out that he committed at least 2 more murders. A couple in Vermont, Bill and Lorraine Currier. The bodies were never recovered because the abandoned house he left them in was demolished. Had he not told officials, no one would have been able to find them or what happened to them.

He just got away with likely 11 murders. He committed suicide so we won’t ever know how many people he murdered. For Bill and Loraine, he dug up a kill bucket that he had buried in the ground 2 years before. The creep buried kill buckets all over the country and just waited until he felt like killing someone.

He didn’t have a type or a method. I think that is what scares me. We think of serial killers like Ted Bundy who preyed on young pretty women, but Keyes would take just about anyone. Age, gender, race… no preference. In a creepy confession he did say he preferred “lighter” people simply because it was easier for disposal. Yep, I almost peed myself too.

If you want to see these creepy interviews, many of them are on youtube and I have linked below.



American Predator: The Hunt for the Most Meticulous Serial Killer of the 21st Century by Maureen Callahan – (I was provided an ARC for this book, but I believe it is the most comprehensive of the resources. It goes on sale July 2, 2019.)


My Favorite Murder | Episode 46

Crime Junkie | Episode 81

Murder Squad | Episode 11

True Crime Bullsh**


Method of a Serial Killer

Youtube of interrogation (6+hrs)

Do you have more information? Let us know your thoughts in the comments!


Follow us!

Twitter || Goodreads || Instagram

Copy of Top Ten Tuesday.png

17 thoughts on “Shot of True Crime | Israel Keyes

  1. What the actual fuck. How have I never heard of this dude? AND HOW CAN YOU BE KIDNAPPED IN FRONT OF PEOPLE HAVE NO ONE NOTICE?! People suck.

    I am glad you recommended American Predator to me, I have the ARC and will be diving into it soon.

    Great job on this post and I hope you continue with the series because ya girl digs it!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I’ve subscribed to the True Crime Bullsh** podcast, but haven’t listened yet – I’m hoarding up all the episodes for when I need a good true crime binge. Kill buckets?!?!?! Gahhhhhhhhhh

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Omg this is super scary it just proved that no one really cares . It’s the old minding my own business … I am a avid reader and writer of this type of stories yet I have never heard of this guy .
    Thanks for the post , it surely will bring awareness… ( nobody is safe)


  4. I cannot read enough about this case, I loved this! So chilling and so clever (in the most sociopathic way possible)
    Amazing job on the post, you’ve definitely found a follower here!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s